For a family already squeezed by Ireland’s tight rental market, losing your home because the landlord says a relative needs it sounds like a nightmare scenario. In County Donegal, that’s exactly what happened to Claire Friel and her family of seven — and their path to justice took nearly three years. On May 8, 2025, a tribunal ordered their landlord to pay €15,000 in damages for unlawfully ending their tenancy.

4 related posts

Damages Awarded: €15,000 · Location: County Donegal, Ireland · Family Size: Seven members · Tribunal Decision Date: 8 May 2025 · Reason for Eviction Claim: Daughter moving in

Quick snapshot

1Confirmed facts
  • Landlord Declan Breslin ordered €15,000 damages by RTB tribunal (The Irish Times)
  • Family of seven — Claire Friel, partner David McLaughlin, and five children — evicted from Termon, Letterkenny home (The Irish Times)
  • Tribunal found termination notice invalid due to landlord’s lack of bona fides (The Irish Times)
2What’s unclear
  • Exact eviction date when family left the property
  • Whether landlord has appealed the RTB decision
  • How long the daughter actually occupied the property post-termination
3Timeline signal
  • Tenancy began 2015; notice issued October 2022; tribunal ruling May 8, 2025 (The Irish Times)
4What’s next
  • Landlord must pay €15,000 damages plus €1,000 in deposit-related orders
  • Stricter eviction rules under 2026 reforms may prevent similar cases
Key facts from the Declan Breslin RTB tribunal case
Detail Value
Landlord Name Declan Breslin
County Donegal
Damages Amount €15,000
Deposit Refund €500
Deposit Penalty €500
Ruling Date 8 May 2025
Tribunal Residential Tenancies Board

What is the 6 year tenant rule?

Ireland’s Residential Tenancies Act provides enhanced protections for tenants who have occupied a property for six or more years. After that threshold, landlords face stricter conditions when seeking to terminate a tenancy — particularly when claiming the property is needed for their own use or that of a family member.

Background on the rule

The rule exists to bring stability to long-term renting. Under the Act, a landlord who wishes to recover a property for family use must demonstrate genuine, indefinite occupation intent. The longer a tenant has lived somewhere, the more scrutiny the landlord’s termination grounds face at tribunal level. Citizens Information tenancy guide explains the notice period requirements for valid terminations.

Application to Donegal case

The family in this case had occupied their Termon home since 2015 — roughly seven years before the notice was issued in October 2022. When Declan Breslin served that notice claiming his daughter needed the property indefinitely, the RTB tribunal examined whether that claim held up under the six-year protection framework. It did not.

The pattern here is clear: long-term tenants gain stronger legal shields, and landlords who cannot demonstrate genuine family-use intentions face tribunal scrutiny that can result in significant financial penalties.

Bottom line: Long-term tenants in Ireland have stronger legal shields against eviction claims that lack genuine supporting evidence.

How much notice does a landlord have to give a tenant to move out in Ireland?

Irish tenancy law sets minimum notice periods that vary based on how long a tenant has lived in the property. For tenancies exceeding six months but under one year, the minimum is 28 days. For those lasting a year or longer, the periods stretch considerably — up to 224 days in some cases for long-term tenants.

Standard notice periods

Under the Residential Tenancies Act, landlords must provide written notice specifying valid grounds for termination. The notice must be served correctly and must include the reason the landlord is seeking possession. Official Residential Tenancies Act text publishes the full legislation covering these requirements.

Exceptions and breaches

When a landlord claims family use as grounds for termination, they must provide evidence that the occupation will be genuine and indefinite. In the Breslin case, the tribunal found the notice fell short of this standard. The adjudicator noted that no evidence was provided that Ms Breslin required the property for indefinite occupation — a requirement the law treats as essential when the claimed ground is family use.

Landlords who issue short-notice terminations without proper evidence expose themselves to damages awards that can far exceed any perceived benefit from removing tenants.

Bottom line: Even when a landlord has a valid-sounding reason to end a tenancy, the law demands proof — and failure to provide it can result in damages awards.

Can a tenant be evicted immediately?

Immediate evictions without proper notice are not permitted under Irish law. The Residential Tenancies Act sets out specific grounds for termination and minimum notice periods that landlords must follow. Failure to comply with these procedures exposes landlords to tribunal claims and financial penalties.

Legal grounds for immediate eviction

Certain serious breaches — such as tenant destruction of property or non-payment of rent — can accelerate the process, but even then, formal notice is required before any physical removal of a tenant. Courts do not look kindly on self-help evictions where landlords simply change locks or remove belongings without authorization. Housing Rights guidance provides detail on what constitutes unlawful eviction.

Consequences of improper action

The Breslin case demonstrates that tribunals will penalize landlords who skip steps or manufacture justifications. The landlord here gave the family only two weeks’ notice, claiming his daughter needed the home — yet his daughter never moved in full-time. The €15,000 damages award reflects the seriousness with which the RTB treats procedural breaches.

The consequence for landlords is straightforward: procedural shortcuts carry real financial risk, regardless of how reasonable the stated reason might sound.

Bottom line: Shortcuts in the eviction process carry real financial risk for landlords, regardless of how reasonable their stated reason might sound.

What are the new rules for landlords in Ireland 2026?

Ireland is tightening landlord obligations in phases, with significant new protections slated for 2026. These changes build on existing tenant safeguards and respond to ongoing concerns about housing instability in the private rental sector.

Upcoming changes

The 2026 reforms aim to further restrict the circumstances under which landlords can reclaim properties from long-term tenants. Proposals include longer notice periods, stricter evidence requirements for family-use terminations, and enhanced penalties for non-compliance. RTB official updates tracks these regulatory developments on its official website.

Impact on eviction practices

If the Breslin ruling sets a precedent, future cases involving questionable family-use claims will face even closer scrutiny. Landlords who assume their word is sufficient when claiming a property is needed for a relative may find themselves facing similar tribunal decisions — and the financial consequences that follow.

For landlords, the regulatory direction points toward stronger tenant protections, making it more important than ever to follow proper procedures — or face the price.

Bottom line: The regulatory direction points toward stronger tenant protections, making it more important than ever for landlords to follow proper procedures — or pay the price.

What happened in the Declan Breslin Donegal tenancy damages case?

Declan Breslin, a landlord in Termon, Letterkenny, issued a notice of termination to his tenant Claire Friel in October 2022, claiming the property was required for his daughter. The family — Friel, her partner David McLaughlin, and their five children — had lived in the home since 2015. Their tenancy had spanned nearly a decade when the notice arrived.

Eviction details

The notice gave the family approximately two weeks to leave. According to tribunal findings, the stated reason was that Breslin’s daughter, Ms Breslin, needed the property for her own indefinite occupation. The family moved out under pressure, ending up in two separate mobile homes — an arrangement the tribunal later described as entirely inappropriate for a family with young children.

Tribunal ruling

When the case reached the RTB tribunal, adjudicators examined whether Breslin’s stated grounds for termination were legitimate. The tribunal found the termination notice invalid. “He gave no evidence and none was provided that Ms Breslin required it for her occupation on an indefinite basis,” the tribunal stated. The adjudicator was not convinced by the bona fides of the landlord’s intentions.

“The tribunal described as ‘profound’ the consequences suffered by Claire Friel and her family of seven.”

— RTB Tribunal findings reported in The Irish Times

“Noting the reason for the termination being that his daughter required the house, expecting to occupy it indefinitely, which would be a valid ground for termination, the tribunal said it was ‘not convinced by the bona fides of the landlord’s intentions’.”

— RTB Tribunal adjudication reported in The Irish Times

What the tribunal found

The adjudicator noted that Ms Breslin only stayed at the property for weekends regularly and never occupied it indefinitely. The landlord provided no evidence that his daughter required the house for genuine long-term use — a fundamental requirement when terminating a tenancy for family occupation.

Timeline of the Declan Breslin tenancy case

The progression from tenancy start to tribunal ruling spans nearly a decade, with the critical events concentrated in a two-year window.

Key events in the Breslin RTB tribunal case
Date Event
2015 Family tenancy begins in Termon, Letterkenny
October 2022 Landlord Declan Breslin issues termination notice for daughter
Post-October 2022 Family relocates to two mobile homes
8 May 2025 RTB tribunal orders €15,000 damages plus €1,000 deposit-related payments

Confirmed facts versus what’s still unclear

Three facts anchor this case with high confidence: the €15,000 damages award, the unlawful termination ruling, and the seven-member family’s displacement into inadequate housing. These points are established across multiple factual records from the tribunal hearing.

Confirmed facts

  • RTB ordered €15,000 damages for unlawful termination
  • €500 deposit refund ordered plus €500 penalty for unlawful retention
  • Family of seven forced to live in two separate mobile homes
  • Tenancy lasted from 2015 until October 2022
  • Tribunal found landlord lacked evidence for family-use claim

Unclear elements

  • Exact date family physically left the property
  • Whether Breslin has filed an appeal
  • How long the daughter occupied the property after termination
  • Whether the daughter ever intended to move in full-time
The pattern in this case

Five verified facts about a landlord, a family, and a tribunal decision — alongside four genuinely unknown elements — tells us something important: tenancy disputes leave paper trails on the formal parts, but the human stories underneath often have gaps that take time to fill.

What the law says and what happened in practice

The Residential Tenancies Act is clear on one point: a landlord who terminates a tenancy claiming family use must genuinely intend for that family member to occupy the property indefinitely. The law exists because landlords have historically used vague family-use justifications as loopholes to remove tenants they simply want out.

In the Breslin case, tribunal adjudicators examined whether the landlord’s stated intentions matched reality. They found they did not. The daughter stayed occasionally on weekends. The landlord provided no documentation that she needed the home on a permanent basis. The termination notice, in the tribunal’s view, was a device to remove long-term tenants — not a genuine step to recover property for family use.

The upshot

The RTB awarded €15,000 specifically because the unlawful termination caused real harm: a family of seven ended up in mobile homes, a consequence the tribunal described as profound. For landlords, the lesson is straightforward — claim family use, and be prepared to prove it.

How tenants can protect themselves

Tenants who receive a notice of termination they believe is invalid have options. They can refer the matter to the RTB for dispute resolution, provide evidence of their own tenancy history, and challenge any claims by landlords about family use that lack documentation. Housing Rights and Citizens Information offer free guidance on tenancy rights and dispute procedures.

The Breslin case shows that tribunal adjudicators do examine the substance of landlord claims — not just the paperwork. A tenant who receives a termination notice claiming family use should gather any evidence that contradicts the landlord’s stated intentions and present it to the RTB. The evidence in this case included records showing the daughter never actually moved in permanently.

Key takeaway for tenants

A notice of termination is not the final word. Tenants who believe their eviction lacks legitimate grounds can challenge it through the RTB — and this case proves the challenge can succeed.

Related reading: Houses for Sale in Rathfarnham · Houses for Sale Gort

Additional sources

thecaretrust.ie

The RTB tribunal ordered Donegal landlord Declan Breslin to pay €15,000 damages for unlawful eviction, as explored in detailed case breakdown.

Don't miss these

Frequently asked questions

Who won the Declan Breslin tenancy case?

The tribunal ruled in favor of tenant Claire Friel and her family of seven. Landlord Declan Breslin was ordered to pay €15,000 in damages for unlawfully terminating the tenancy and an additional €1,000 in deposit-related payments.

What compensation was awarded in the Donegal case?

The RTB tribunal awarded €15,000 in damages for unlawful termination. Additionally, Breslin was ordered to refund the €500 deposit and pay another €500 penalty for unlawfully retaining it.

How to file a tenancy dispute in Ireland?

Tenants can submit a dispute application to the Residential Tenancies Board through its website. The process involves completing an application form, paying a fee, and providing supporting documentation for your case.

What proves unlawful eviction?

Factors that support an unlawful eviction claim include: termination notice lacking valid grounds, failure to provide adequate notice periods, lack of evidence that stated reasons are genuine, and inadequate living arrangements forced upon tenants after termination.

Does the 6-year rule apply to all tenancies?

The six-year rule provides enhanced protections for long-term tenants, but notice periods and eviction rules apply to all residential tenancies. However, the longer a tenant has lived in a property, the more scrutiny a landlord’s termination grounds face at tribunal level.

What happens if a landlord ignores notice rules?

Landlords who fail to follow proper notice procedures face RTB tribunal claims and potential damages awards. The Breslin case resulted in €16,000 in total orders against the landlord for procedural breaches.

Are 2026 landlord rules retroactive?

The 2026 landlord reforms in Ireland will apply to tenancies created or renewed after the legislation takes effect. Existing cases like the Breslin tribunal ruling will not be reopened, but future termination notices will face stricter requirements.

The broader stakes for Irish tenants and landlords

The Breslin case lands at a moment when Ireland’s rental sector is under intense scrutiny. Housing advocates have long argued that tenant protections need stronger enforcement mechanisms — and tribunal decisions like this one demonstrate that enforcement does happen, but often only after families have already been displaced.

For tenants, the message is mixed: the system can deliver justice, but navigating it takes time, resources, and legal knowledge that many renters lack. Organizations like Housing Rights offer support, but access to that support remains uneven across Ireland’s regions.

The implication

For tenants in Donegal and across Ireland, the lesson is simple: document everything, know your rights, and don’t assume a landlord’s stated reason for eviction is automatically valid. For landlords, the message from the RTB is equally clear — if you’re claiming family use, have the evidence ready, or expect to pay for the shortfall.

For renters facing similar situations, the path forward is clear: challenge improper notices, seek advice from housing advocates, and understand that tribunals do examine the substance behind landlord claims — not just the paperwork. The €15,000 awarded to Claire Friel’s family reflects a system that can protect tenants, but only when those tenants know how to use it.